Parallel Construction
in Questions
The verbs do and have can cause problems with
parallelism, especially when they are used as auxiliary
(helping) verbs in questions and negative situations. The
following are examples of
incorrect, non-parallel use of
these verbs in questions.

Have you got as much time as I do?
Do you have as much time as I have?

In both of these sentences, the auxiliary verbs do not
correspond. The sentences should read

Have you got as much time as I have?
Do you have as much time as I do?

The second question may be especially troublesome
because both do and have are present.

To avoid making errors in parallelism, it may be helpful to
remember the rules of short answers to questions: if a
question begins with
have, the correct response is ‘Yes, I
have’ or ‘No, I have not’; likewise, if a question starts with
do, the correct response is ‘’Yes, I do’ or ‘No, I do not’.

Negative statements also make use of auxiliary verbs; the
rules of parallelism are the same as those for questions. The
following two sentences are
incorrect be cause the verbs
are
not parallel.

You have not got as much time as I do.
You
do not have as much time as I have.

Again, the first sentence may see more obviously incorrect
than the first. Try to remember that, as in short answers to
questions, it is the auxiliary verbs that should correspond.
The two example sentences would be correctly written:

You have not got as much time as I have.
You
do not have as much time as I do.
Have you skated
as long as they
have?
Do you skate as
well as they
do?
Woman: Do you
want to try out for
the Olympics?
Man: Yes, I
do.
Man: Have you got
a routine in mind?
Woman: No, I
haven't.
Free Praxis Prep is a service of Multicultural Education Programs at the University of Southern Maine
About Us   Using this Material   Contact Us   Linking